Gilbert pizza ranges from thin-crust Southern Italian pies to a wood fired pizza truck. Prices are mostly moderate, and catering is common here. Several of the places have patios.
Sal's Gilbert Pizza serves thin-crust pizza and old-school pasta under murals of Italy, and it is rated 4.6 from 2,841 reviews. Buono's Pizza Higley makes New York-style pies with fresh dough daily and sauces made in house. Fire & Brimstone Pizza Restaurant bakes wood fired pizzas with imaginative toppings.
Don Guerra's Barrio Bagel & Slice sells sourdough bagels and pizza slices from heritage grains, and The Pizza Butcher caters events from a wood fired truck. Grotti's Pizza goes for pickle pizza and sweet heat pizza. Salerno's serves Chicago pizza next to thin crust pies. For other cravings, Best Mexican Food in Gilbert is one page over.
Sponsored: Pizza in Gilbert
Best Pizza in Gilbert
-
Sal's Gilbert Pizza
Thin-crust pizza and old-school pasta come out of Sal's Gilbert Pizza, a Southern Italian pizzeria in Gilbert with murals of Italy on the walls.
- Italian
- $$
- Happy hour
- Patio
1150 S Gilbert Rd, Gilbert
(480) 633-22264.6 Google rating 2,841 Google reviews -
Flancer's Incredible Sandwiches & Pizza
Pizzas, burgers and sandwiches built on homemade bread come out of Flancer's Incredible Sandwiches & Pizza, a homey, dinerlike eatery in Gilbert.
- Burgers
- $$
- Happy hour
- Brunch
610 N Gilbert Rd, Gilbert
(480) 926-90774.5 Google rating 1,374 Google reviews -
Salerno's
Chicago pizza, thin crust pies and rustic pasta come out of Salerno's, an Italian eatery in Gilbert dating to circa 1966.
- $$
- Happy hour
- Reservations
3921 E Guadalupe Rd, Gilbert
(480) 892-00404.6 Google rating 1,093 Google reviews -
Buono's Pizza Higley
The family behind the original Buono's is back with Buono's Pizza Higley, a New York-style pizzeria in Gilbert that makes its dough fresh daily and its sauces in house.
- $$
- Patio
1652 N Higley Rd #103, Gilbert
(480) 218-23384.8 Google rating 792 Google reviews -
Buono’s Pizza
Established in 1989, Buono’s Pizza returned to Gilbert after customers asked the owners to reopen.
- $$
- Patio
1464 E Williams Field Rd #108, Gilbert
(480) 899-12004.6 Google rating 646 Google reviews -
Fire & Brimstone Pizza Restaurant
Wood fired pizzas with imaginative toppings and locally sourced ingredients are the focus of Fire & Brimstone Pizza Restaurant in Gilbert.
- Italian
- Mediterranean
- Vegan
- $$
- Patio
- Vegan options
3000 E Ray Rd Bldg 6 suite 101, Gilbert
(480) 687-34904.5 Google rating 674 Google reviews -
Eatalio Pasta & Wine
Eatalio Pasta & Wine is a warm, relaxed Italian eatery in Gilbert with modern dishes, wine and cocktails, and catering for special occasions.
- Italian
- $$
- Happy hour
- Patio
6348 S Higley Rd #106, Gilbert
(480) 625-38604.5 Google rating 444 Google reviews -
Don Guerra's Barrio Bagel & Slice
Baker Don Guerra, a James Beard Award winner, serves sourdough bagels and pizza slices baked from heritage grains grown locally at Don Guerra's Barrio Bagel & Slice in Gilbert, along N Arizona Ave, close to Guadalupe Rd. The everything bagel, rosemary sea salt bagel, chiltepin cream cheese, a chocolate cherry roll and cold brew get named.
- $
- Patio
- Brunch
689 N Arizona Ave, Gilbert
(480) 548-81344.5 Google rating 311 Google reviews -
Rino D's Pizza & Wings
A counter-serve pizzeria in Gilbert, Rino D's Pizza & Wings does hand-tossed pies, calzones, pastas and other Italian basics.
- Wings
- Italian
- Mediterranean
- $$
- Late night
1515 N Gilbert Rd #114, Gilbert
(480) 545-27004.3 Google rating 350 Google reviews -
Grotti's Pizza
Pickle pizza, sweet heat pizza and a buffalo pie set Grotti's Pizza apart from the usual slice shop.
- $
7131 S Val Vista Dr #103, Gilbert
(480) 810-19104.3 Google rating 92 Google reviews -
The Pizza Butcher
A wood fired pizza truck, The Pizza Butcher caters events around Gilbert, Phoenix, Scottsdale, Chandler, Tempe, Mesa and Queen Creek.
- $
575 E Germann Rd, Gilbert
(480) 369-23245.0 Google rating 37 Google reviews
Ratings and review counts from Google, November 2026. Ranked by rating weighted by review count.