Restaurants in Eagar, AZ

Restaurants in Eagar lean toward pizza and American comfort food. Four places share this page: Trailriders Family Restaurant & Bar, Pizza, Little Pink House and Noble Romans Pizza. Two of them are pizza kitchens, and the price levels run mostly inexpensive, with one at the moderate level.

Trailriders Family Restaurant & Bar carries the longest review history on the page, 4.5 from 1,385 reviews. Prime rib, chicken fried steak, enchiladas and chili rellenos are on the menu, along with green chili, green corn tamales, a chimichanga and a salad bar. Breakfast comes with hash browns and buttermilk syrup. The place offers brunch, happy hour, a private dining room, reservations and catering.

Little Pink House is a quaint restaurant in a house built in 1912, with vintage decor, rated 4.8 from 64 reviews. Brie and pear sandwiches, homemade bread, soups, salads, desserts and strawberry lemonade fill the menu, and there are vegetarian, vegan and gluten free options. It serves brunch, opens its outdoor seating in summer and caters.

Best restaurants in Eagar

  1. Trailriders Family Restaurant & Bar

    Prime rib, chicken fried steak, enchiladas and chili rellenos are on the menu at Trailriders Family Restaurant & Bar in Eagar, with green chili, green corn tamales, a chimichanga and a salad bar.

    • American
    • $$
    • Happy hour
    • Brunch

    140 N Main St, Eagar

    (928) 333-1446
    4.5 Google rating 1,385 Google reviews
  2. Pizza

    Pizza in Eagar with a sausage pizza, a pickle pizza, a pepperoni and mushroom pizza and a garlic butter crust, plus a Philly cheese steak, a smash burger and wings in garlic parmesan and teriyaki.

    • Pizza
    • $

    367 N Main St, Eagar

    (928) 333-1144
    4.5 Google rating 118 Google reviews
  3. Little Pink House

    Brie and pear sandwiches, homemade bread and chocolate cake share the table at Little Pink House in Eagar, a quaint restaurant in a house built in 1912 with vintage decor.

    • $
    • Patio
    • Brunch

    214 N Main St, Eagar

    (928) 245-5163
    4.8 Google rating 64 Google reviews
  4. Noble Romans Pizza

    Noble Romans Pizza is a pizza restaurant in Eagar, and diners talk about its gas station pizza and the staff.

    • Pizza
    • $

    12 S Main St, Eagar

    (928) 333-2697
    4.3 Google rating 12 Google reviews

Ratings and review counts from Google, November 2026. Ranked by rating weighted by review count.

The restaurant called Pizza is rated 4.5 from 118 reviews, 95 of them five stars. A sausage pizza, a pickle pizza, a pepperoni and mushroom pizza and a garlic butter crust share the menu with a Philly cheese steak, a smash burger and wings in garlic parmesan and teriyaki. Mini air hockey is on hand, and the cost stays low.

Noble Romans Pizza is an inexpensive stop rated 4.3 from 12 reviews, 8 of them five stars. Diners talk about its gas station pizza and the staff, and the gas station setting is part of how people describe it. It does not take reservations.

Diners looking beyond Eagar can open the pages for Springerville, Greer, Alpine, St Johns and Pinetop.

Common questions about restaurants in Eagar

Where can I get brunch in Eagar?

Trailriders Family Restaurant & Bar and Little Pink House both serve brunch. Trailriders makes breakfast with hash browns and buttermilk syrup, while Little Pink House pairs brunch with brie and pear sandwiches, homemade bread and chocolate cake.

Which Eagar restaurant has outdoor seating?

Little Pink House has outdoor seating, and it opens in summer. The restaurant sits in a house built in 1912, serves brunch and also caters.

Is there a private room for a group meal in Eagar?

Trailriders Family Restaurant & Bar has a private dining room. It also takes reservations, runs a happy hour and offers catering, so it covers most group plans. Noble Romans Pizza does not take reservations.

Where can I find pizza in Eagar?

The restaurant called Pizza makes sausage, pickle, and pepperoni and mushroom pizzas with a garlic butter crust, and Noble Romans Pizza is the other pizza restaurant here. Pizza is rated 4.5 from 118 reviews and Noble Romans Pizza is rated 4.3 from 12 reviews.

Which nearby towns have their own page?

Springerville, Greer, Alpine, St Johns and Pinetop each have a page of their own, for diners who want to look past Eagar.

Restaurants near Eagar