Original #1 Brothers Pizza

4.7(1,076 reviews on Google)

Restaurant listing in Peoria, AZ

About Original #1 Brothers Pizza

A basic spot serving NYC-style thin crust pizza, Original #1 Brothers Pizza in Peoria also sells wings, subs and Italian staples such as eggplant parm and meatball subs. It is family owned, the crispy wings get attention, and late night food is on hand, at a moderate price level. Rated 4.7 from 1,076 Google reviews, 909 of them five stars.

What Google reviewers mention: wings (200), ny style pizza (24), subs (13), friendly workers (10), family owned (9), thin crust pizza (4), crispy wings (3), eggplant parm (2), meatball sub (2), greasy pizza (2)

What it offers

  • Late-night food

    Yes
  • Takes reservationsNo

No information yet on brunch, happy hour, private dining room, patio or outdoor seating, vegan options, catering, fine dining, rooftop seating. Google's listing does not say; call and ask.

Price level on Google: Moderate ($$).

On these lists:

Contact

Listing compiled from public sources on 2026-11-20. Report a correction or request removal. Back to restaurants in Peoria.