That Guy's Pizza

3.9(227 reviews on Google)

Restaurant listing in Fountain Hills, AZ

About That Guy's Pizza

Pizza, calzones and other Italian staples come in a room with brick walls and New York City decor at That Guy's Pizza in Fountain Hills. NY style pizza, thin crust, wings, subs and an antipasti salad are on the menu, and online ordering is available. Happy hour and reservations come along, at an inexpensive check. Rated 3.9 from 227 Google reviews, 134 of them five stars.

What Google reviewers mention: wings (10), calzones (8), friendly owners (8), pie (7), sub (6), ny style pizza (5), thin crust (4), antipasti salad (2), online ordering (2), local place (2)

What it offers

  • Happy hour

    Yes
  • Takes reservations

    Yes

No information yet on brunch, private dining room, patio or outdoor seating, late-night food, vegan options, catering, fine dining, rooftop seating. Google's listing does not say; call and ask.

Price level on Google: Inexpensive ($).

Contact

Listing compiled from public sources on 2026-11-20. Report a correction or request removal. Back to restaurants in Fountain Hills.