New Jersey Pizza Co

4.5(356 reviews on Google)

Restaurant listing in Flagstaff, AZ

About New Jersey Pizza Co

New Jersey Pizza Co is a Flagstaff pizzeria making New York style pies with a thin, crispy, foldable crust. The margarita pie, the chucho pizza and a vegan pizza with homemade cashew cheese are on the menu, with hummus on the side. Rated 4.5 from 356 Google reviews, 277 of them five stars.

What Google reviewers mention: hummus (22), pies (18), vegan pizza (11), new york style pizza (5), greasy pizza (5), homemade cashew cheese (2), chucho pizza (2), foldable crust (2), thin and crispy crust (2), margarita pie (2)

What it offers

  • Takes reservationsNo

No information yet on brunch, happy hour, private dining room, patio or outdoor seating, late-night food, vegan options, catering, fine dining, rooftop seating. Google's listing does not say; call and ask.

Price level on Google: Moderate ($$).

On these lists:

Contact

Listing compiled from public sources on 2026-11-20. Report a correction or request removal. Back to restaurants in Flagstaff.